Text & Visuals | Dua Abbas Rizvi
–
Issue 44
–
Too many of us have become accustomed to readying ourselves to view art – as one readies oneself to interact with a hallowed space or an official one. The exhibiting and viewing of art, as we largely know them today, are acts of purpose and preparation, ritualism and method. Works are displayed in a certain way inside spaces that have come to be known as white cubes. These spaces may not always be white, or cubical, but the term has become synonymous with a modern gallery aesthetic that prescribes a selective and orderly display of artworks on, or within, unblemished and even walls. These walls contain no orifices, like windows, and are lit by artificial lighting that can be tempered into consistency. What these spaces aspire to is neutrality, de-contextualization, and a distancing of art from the heterogeneity, temporality, and complexity of life.
The idea of the sterilized, white gallery developed in the twentieth century in tandem with formalist concerns in art. Though adopted and favored by European groups like De Stijl and the Bauhaus (and even the Third Reich) during the earliest decades of the twentieth century, the white cube is generally thought to have been institutionalized by American art historian Alfred Barr, by means of his 1936 exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art, New York, titled Cubism and Abstract Art. The exhibition involved a marked simplification of the interior, a whitening of walls and ceiling, and a chronological arrangement of works that eschewed any socio-political or interpretative approach to the display. The works, Barr insisted, were to be seen for themselves only.
Modern art, with its emphasis on pure form, its shrugging off of context and symbolic baggage, its move towards a kind of cleansing and purging of the extraneous, invited and embraced the impassiveness of the white cube. Such a space terminated a viewer’s contact with the world, transforming the art inside into esoterica and the experience of viewing into a purely visual and cerebral activity. Irish art critic and artist Brian O’Doherty famously ruminated on these alienating aspects of the white cube in a ground-breaking series of essays published in Artforum in 1976 (and compiled later into a book titled Inside the White Cube: The Ideology of the Gallery Space). O’Doherty suggests that art inside a white cube “exists in a kind of eternity of display, and though there is lots of ‘period’ (late modern), there is no time.” He goes on to write:
“The eternity gives the gallery a limbolike status; one has to have died already to be there. Indeed, the presence of that odd piece of furniture, your own body, seems superfluous, and intrusion. The space offers the thought that while eyes and minds are welcome, space-occupying bodies are not—or are tolerated only as kinesthetic mannequins for further study…Here at last the spectator, oneself, is eliminated. You are there without being there.”
This hermetic setup leaves little, if any, room for processual or emotive presentation and understanding of art. It produces a remove between art and humanness, which alternative exhibitions, or displays of art in alternative spaces, seek to remedy. Protest and dissent are crucial to creating and there have been many instances of artists challenging the status quo by taking into their own hands the display and dissemination of their art. Sophie-Carolin Wagner, in a paper titled Art Space Archaeology (published in the online scholarly journal continent.), refers to 18th-century Irish painter Nathaniel Hone as the artist and curator behind the “first noted” artist-run space and alternative exhibition. After one of his paintings satirizing Joshua Reynolds, the president of the Royal Academy of Arts (London), was rejected by the Academy for its annual exhibition of 1775, Hone rented a space near the Academy’s gallery and exhibited his rejected painting, and others, in a show he labelled “The exhibition of pictures by Nathaniel Hone: mostly the works of his leisure, and many of them in his own possession”.
The move not only presaged a subsequent link between exhibitions in alternative spaces and greater artistic freedoms, it also countered the inevitable commodification of art that occurs in conventional galleries. And though earlier dissidents like Hone may not have acted out of a desire to establish an alternative model of art-making and art-sharing, numerous alternative exhibitions since have certainly been attempts at doing so. Swiss curator Hans Ulrich Obrist’s World Soup, or the kitchen show, is an important example. In 1991, Obrist curated an exhibition in the kitchen of his apartment in St. Gallen, Switzerland. He recounts the experience in Ways of Curating and discusses why the idea appealed to him and the artists who collaborated with him – “To do a show there would mix art and life, naturally.” The kitchen show can be seen as prototypical of some of the concerns that continue to define Obrist’s curatorial practice: conversation, collaboration, the informal and the candid, the natural, the procedural. “It wasn’t an art exhibition in the kitchen, no,” he writes. “The art took place in-between.”
The alternative art space holds huge promise for contemporary practitioners. Our times are witness to ubiquitous debates over the accretion and abuse of power by institutions and certain sectors of society. Activism is an integral part of the millennial experience and alternative frameworks for the creation and exhibition of art offer young artists and curators in Pakistan, too, the room to be seen and heard when that room is not found in the cultural mainstream. In Karachi, in 2016, recent alumni of the Indus Valley School of Art and Architecture exhibited artworks in an abandoned apartment near the historic Denso Hall, on M. A. Jinnah Road, under the title of Pehli Manzil (First Storey). The works were made in response to the once-domestic space and addressed, among other topics, social expectations around gender and the effects of unchecked urbanisation on local flora and fauna.
In Lahore, artist-run initiative The Creative Process has held two exhibitions in alternative spaces since its formation in 2017. There are several factors that make The Creative Process a unique and pertinent presence in the local arts community. For starters, the group welcomes members of all ages and educational backgrounds, as long as an interest in art and artistic discourse is evinced. The group’s projects have been robustly collaborative, and have followed egalitarian procedures for selection. This was particularly heartening to witness with regards to the group’s second show, River in an Ocean, which took place in Lahore during the inaugural Lahore Biennale. The exhibition was the result of an open call for proposals for individual or collaborative projects (with a focus on gender and sexuality and their relationship with history, power, and resistance) and comprised perhaps the most diverse assortment of artists and artistic expressions in the entire biennale.
River in an Ocean was curated by visual artists Natasha Malik and Abdullah Qureshi (co-founders of The Creative Process) in a temporarily vacant warehouse on a busy thoroughfare in Lahore. Inspired by the activism, ideology, and artistic practice of Lala Rukh, the exhibition, taking cue from its name (a title of one of Lala Rukh’s works), looked at ways in which difference can be owned and celebrated and one’s identity and beliefs maintained in the face of pressure to conform. Works in the exhibition dealt with issues, and involved mediums, that do not often find representation in local shows or homebred art movements. Multiple performances, videos playing on unlikely surfaces, photographs and prints of a vivid range of sizes, drawings and doodles and text strewn all over the place made the show a loud, living, urgent mess. So, in addition to subverting existing patterns of, and motivations behind, art-making, the exhibition also defied the idea of an exhibition space being airtight and inviolate by situating art amidst industrial debris and din, human and vehicular commotion, and inconsistent, here-tenebrous, there-beatific lighting.
The Creative Process had achieved something similar in 2017, with their first show, Of Other Spaces, curated by Natasha Malik. In an empty, old-fashioned, ruined house in a formerly posh, residential quarter of Lahore (a house scheduled for imminent demolition and also used by Lahore-based visual artist Rabia Aijaz for her solo show earlier), the group had installed artworks that had navigated the shared and murky psychological space of memory, sorrow, and historical erasure even as they had provided visitors with new ways to navigate a physical space whose original purpose had been lost. Inspired by Michel Foucault’s 1967 lecture of the same name, Of Other Spaces had been a vigil, an experiment, an intervention, a dalliance – all at once. And it is this possibility of pluralism, allowed and activated in alternative spaces, that makes them increasingly relevant today. Sophie-Carolin Wagner, in Art Space Archaeology, posits:
“While museums as archival and conservational institutions need to establish an aura of timelessness and permanence, artist-run spaces can embrace their inherent mortality by being vigorously impermanent and focusing on highly temporal outbursts of artistic energy – rapidly expanding in every physical, thinkable or discursive dimension. This continuous process of deconstructing and rethinking strategies, frameworks, audiences, and formats of contemporary art and its spaces, allows these initiatives to become platforms for the discourse on artistic agency in an age of a widespread crisis of institutions.”
When Can My Cialis Ship where to buy cialis online forum 36 Equilibrium radioligand binding studies using human cells demonstrate that dapoxetine binds to 5-HT, norepinephrine NE and dopamine DA re-uptake transporters and inhibits uptake in the following order of potency NE DA
Drug Approval Package priligy online pharmacy
ADVERTISING SECTIONS Editorial-looking sections or pages that are not produced by a magazine s editors are not editorial content buy cialis 5mg online
My Son Has Decided He Wants His Skin Tags Removed What Do We Do Now where to buy cialis Begins to work in 30 minutes, the effect lasts for 4-5 hours
Damage to your liver cirrhosis and kidneys renal failure can affect your body s production of testosterone. clomid without prescriptions mexico
buy doxycycline
In rheumatology, this group of immunosuppressants, the classical chemotherapies, is reserved for treatment of patients with severe organ involvement, usually of connective tissue disease or vasculitis how long does lasix stay in your system The following year, I turned 33 and discovered that my life wasn t going back to normal
Montenegro IS, Kuhl CP, Schneider RA, Zachia SA, Durli ICLO, Terraciano PB, Rivero RC, Passos EP cialis generic reviews levitra diclofenac ratiopharm 30 mg g gel However, the report notes that Internet usage has increased significantly in the developing world during the past five years
Bone trephine biopsies were more likely to be positive in ILC buy stromectol tablets The methodological quality of randomized controlled trials of homeopathy, herbal medicines and acupuncture
Новый сериал
Medicine 1977; 56 255 286 priligy dapoxetine amazon Using a concentration range of 4 OH TAM 1 10 ОјM for trans 4 OH TAM and 1 15 ОјM for cis 4 OH TAM and a specific incubation time 30 min, the apparent K m values and the V max K m ratios for UGT1A4 induced glucuronidation of trans 4 OH TAM and of cis 4 OH TAM were 2
E Number of Oct4 GFP colonies generated by EpiSCs stably transfected with GY118F and either Klf4 or Nanog then transferred to 2i Gcsf for 8 days tamoxifen uterine cancer There is biophysical and pharmacological evidence that I Clswell in immune cells differs from the more common volumeregulated anion channel VRAC
Is it dawn Xu Congee got up from the ground, then looked up at the does saw palmetto increase testosterone sky, she herself was a little surprised, there was not even a little sunshine Male Enhancement Pills For Ed condom causes erectile dysfunction in this place what is clomiphene therapy
Hot flashes are kundalini training sessions what does lasix look like Obesity and breast density are both associated with an increased risk of breast cancer and are potentially modifiable
verified canadian pharmacy best ed medication
https://metformin.pro/# price of metformin 850 mg
https://metformin.pro/# metformin 800
[url=https://zithromaxpills.store/#]zithromax 250mg[/url] zithromax online
https://pharmacyshippingtousa.icu/# trusted online pharmacy
[url=https://canadiandrugpharmacy.best/#]canada drug pharmacy[/url] vipps approved canadian online pharmacy
buying sildenafil uk where to get sildenafil
https://datingsiteonline.site/# free dating sites
https://tadalafil20mg.fun/# tadalafil tablets 20 mg online
[url=https://sildenafil100mg.store/#]sildenafil over the counter[/url] can i purchase sildenafil over the counter
free date site dating women online
https://canadiandrugpharmacy.best/# medication canadian pharmacy
https://datingsiteonline.site/# dating chat site
[url=https://sildenafil100mg.store/#]sildenafil 1mg[/url] sildenafil 6mg
https://canadiandrugpharmacy.best/# canadadrugpharmacy com
sildenafil 50mg prices sildenafil soft gel
https://datingsiteonline.site/# ourtime free trial
[url=https://datingsiteonline.site/#]plenty of fish sign in[/url] totally free dating service
The aromatase inhibitors are the drugs of choice in these circumstance buy online cialis Will this remove good estrogen I have and need
https://datingonlinehot.online/# meet local singles free
https://datingonlinehot.online/# free adult dating sites
[url=https://datingonlinehot.com/#]local women dates[/url] searchingforsingles
https://datingonlinehot.online/# singles site
https://datingonlinehot.com/# marriage not dating
[url=https://datingonlinehot.online/#]free date sites[/url] free dating chatting online
The SF 12 is a 12 item short form of the SF 36 Health Status Questionnaire, a generic health related quality of life instrument 41, 42 cialis from usa pharmacy 118 1996 10651071 Crossref PubMed ISI Google Scholar 5 Criddle D
https://cheapestedpills.com/# best ed treatment pills
https://cheapestedpills.com/# ed meds
[url=https://cheapestedpills.com/#]new ed treatments[/url] ed pills cheap
https://cheapestedpills.com/# best pill for ed
https://cheapestedpills.com/# male ed drugs
[url=https://cheapestedpills.shop/#]medicine for erectile[/url] pills for ed
https://noprescriptioncanada.com/# online ed drugs no prescription
The average Fraction Modern value of DNA from tamoxifen treated patients in study 2, after subtraction of the carrier contribution, was 2 what is the shelf life of viagra By contrast, no effect was observed on active R Ras levels when Rasa3 was knockdown in the later cells
https://noprescriptioncanada.com/# canadian rx pharmacy
[url=https://noprescriptioncanada.shop/#]best pharmacy prices[/url] mail order pharmacy
https://noprescriptioncanada.shop/# over the counter drug store
https://noprescriptioncanada.com/# safe online pharmacy
[url=https://noprescriptioncanada.com/#]best canadian pharmacy[/url] mexico pharmacy order online
accutane hair loss cialis ibuprofen 400 mg zonder voorschrift The judge, Army Col
https://noprescriptioncanada.shop/# online prescription
https://noprescriptioncanada.com/# overseas online pharmacy
https://noprescriptioncanada.com/# pharcharmy online no script
Its oral bioavailability is excellent and it is a well tolerated and effective palliative regimen 36 hour cialis online
canadian pharcharmy online viagra online drugstore reviews
https://noprescriptioncanada.shop/# online canadian pharmacy no prescription
[url=https://stromectolst.com/#]stromectol liquid[/url] ivermectin 250ml
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin tablets
[url=https://stromectolst.com/#]ivermectin cream cost[/url] ivermectin 3mg
ivermectin usa ivermectin buy australia
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 1 cream
[url=https://stromectolst.com/#]ivermectin canada[/url] ivermectin humans
buy ivermectin nz ivermectin rx
https://stromectolst.com/# ivermectin 5
[url=https://stromectolst.com/#]ivermectin new zealand[/url] ivermectin cost uk
how much is ivermectin how much is ivermectin
ivermectin drug stromectol order online
buy ivermectin pills ivermectin 50 mg
ivermectin price ivermectin 8 mg
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]online pharmacy without scripts[/url] online pharmacy usa
safe canadian pharmacy cheapest online pharmacy
https://drugs1st.com/# online pharmacy com
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]canadian online pharmacy no prescription[/url] express scripts com pharmacies
top online pharmacy 247 mexican pharmacy online
https://drugs1st.shop/# online pharmacy store
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]canadian online pharmacy no prescription[/url] pharmacy discount card
pharmacy home delivery canadian online pharmacy no prescription
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]canadian pharmacy without prescription[/url] online canadian pharmacy review
best canadian online pharmacy reviews canadian online pharmacy no prescription
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]cheapest online pharmacy[/url] reputable canadian online pharmacies
https://drugs1st.com/# generic viagra online canadian pharmacy
[url=https://drugs1st.com/#]no rx pharmacy[/url] canadian pharmacy for viagra
canadian pharmacy discount coupon us online pharmacy
https://drugs1st.com/# legal online pharmacies in the us
[url=https://drugs1st.shop/#]online pharmacy without scripts[/url] canadian pharmacy ltd
canadian pharmacies compare mexican pharmacy online
https://drugs1st.com/# california pharmacy
[url=https://drugs1st.shop/#]canadian online pharmacy no prescription[/url] online pharmacy reddit
https://drugs1st.shop/# best online pharmacy
pharmacies in canada that ship to the us canadian online pharmacy no prescription
[url=https://amoxil1st.store/#]can you buy amoxicillin over the counter[/url] where can i buy amoxicillin over the counter
buy doxycycline online nz order doxycycline 100mg without prescription
[url=https://prednisone1st.store/#]prednisone 20 mg purchase[/url] mail order prednisone
can you buy amoxicillin over the counter in canada generic amoxicillin
[url=https://cipro1st.store/#]ciprofloxacin mail online[/url] cipro pharmacy
amoxicillin for sale online amoxicillin 500 mg brand name
[url=https://prednisone1st.store/#]prednisone 40 mg[/url] prednisone prices
zithromax without prescription zithromax capsules
[url=https://zithromax1st.store/#]zithromax 500 mg for sale[/url] zithromax price canada
ciprofloxacin order online buy ciprofloxacin
[url=https://cipro1st.store/#]cipro pharmacy[/url] buy cipro online without prescription
40mg doxycycline online doxycycline order canada
[url=https://edpills.science/#]erectile dysfunction medicines[/url] best over the counter ed pills
propecia india finasteride 5 mg prices
[url=https://propecia1st.science/#]propecia without a doctor prescription[/url] where can i buy propecia
natural remedies for ed ed meds online
[url=https://edpills.science/#]cheap erectile dysfunction pill[/url] male erection pills
https://clomid1st.science/# clomid online usa
ed treatment review otc ed pills
[url=https://prednisone1st.science/#]25 mg prednisone[/url] prednisone 40 mg
[url=https://propecia1st.science/#]where to get propecia[/url] buy finasteride no rx
cheapest ed pills best ed treatment pills
https://propecia1st.science/# finasteride 1 mg
[url=https://edpills.science/#]medication for ed[/url] ed drug prices
buy clomid canada clomid tablets india
https://edpills.science/# new ed pills
[url=https://clomid1st.science/#]clomid 50 mg order online[/url] clomid free shipping
ed remedies what is the best ed pill
secure generic pills cheap generic ed pills
canadian 24 hour pharmacy reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
https://indiapharmacy.store/# ed drugs online from india
https://canadianpharmacy.icu/# reliable canadian online pharmacy
https://canadianpharmacy.icu/# certified canadian international pharmacy
free dating site chatting free single dating online
https://datingonline1st.shop/# mature dating sites free no credit card fees
personals free free online dating and personals
https://datingonline1st.com/# singles in women
https://datingonline1st.shop/# local online dating sites
online dating site single women online
https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/# uti over the counter medication
[url=https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/#]apoquel over the counter substitute[/url] over the counter health and wellness products
over the counter eye drops for pink eye best allergy medications over-the-counter
[url=https://drugsoverthecounter.shop/#]over the counter antibiotic[/url] over the counter pills like viagra
Great article! Your article helped me a lot. Thanks! What do you think? I want to share your article to my website: gate 交易所
https://drugsoverthecounter.com/# best over the counter nausea medicine
omeprazole over the counter sleep aids over the counter
[url=https://drugsoverthecounter.com/#]over the counter pill identifier[/url] strongest over the counter diuretic
best over the counter teeth whitening uti over the counter medicine
bronchial inhalers over the counter over the counter medicine
https://drugsoverthecounter.com/# over the counter bladder control
[url=https://drugsoverthecounter.com/#]diuretics over the counter[/url] best over the counter medicine for sore throat
buying cialis online Factors that can contribute to your baby being overdue or a postterm pregnancy are often unknown, but can include
best sleeping pills over the counter allergy medications over-the-counter
Studbook I, SSP Coordinator Training and Science of Zoo and Aquarium Animal Management Courses, 22 26 February 1994 at the AAZPA Conservation Academy, St ivermectin 3mg price If protective measures were widely adopted, they could significantly reduce women s chances of ever getting breast cancer
https://over-the-counter-drug.com/# over the counter medicine for acid reflux
[url=https://over-the-counter-drug.com/#]pills like viagra over the counter cvs[/url] best over the counter gas and bloating medicine
best over the counter teeth whitening is viagra over the counter
[url=https://over-the-counter-drug.com/#]nausea medication over the counter[/url] over the counter sleep aids that work
is viagra bad for your heart You ll notice that puppies who are experiencing puppy strangles often exhibit other signs that something is wrong
[url=https://over-the-counter-drug.com/#]is viagra over the counter[/url] over the counter anxiety meds
over the counter cold sore medicine over the counter antibiotic
to a drug acute interstitial allergic nephritis half life of lasix
https://stromectol.science/# ivermectin usa
[url=https://doxycycline.science/#]doxycycline medication[/url] doxycycline mono
https://amoxil.science/# where to buy amoxicillin pharmacy
https://stromectol.science/# minocycline ointment
[url=https://doxycycline.science/#]buy cheap doxycycline online[/url] doxycycline 150 mg